Blog

How to Correct a Background Check Mistake that Cost You a Job

How to Correct a Background Check Mistake that Cost You a Job
Reviewed By: Daniel Cohen, Esq.
|
Last Updated: October 20, 2026

My Background Check is Wrong. How Can I Correct The Mistake?

You aced the interviews, connected with the team, and finally received that hopeful call, the job offer is yours, contingent on a background check. Then, silence. 

The rejection email arrives, citing something on your report. The shock and confusion are profound, especially when you know the information is wrong. 

A mistake on a background check isn’t just a clerical error; it’s a door slammed shut on a future you earned. The emotional and financial toll can be significant, from lost income and benefits to a blow to your professional confidence. 

But please know this: You have powerful rights under the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA), and a clear, though often challenging, path to correct the record and seek justice.

Background screening companies are required by law to ensure the information they report is accurate and up-to-date. When they fail, and that failure costs you a job, the FCRA provides a framework to dispute the error and recover damages for the harm caused. Taking action requires a calm, systematic approach to overturn the mistake and get back on the career path you're building.

What to Do If Your Background Check Is Wrong

If a background check error costs you a job or puts a job offer at risk, here are the essential steps to take:

1. Review The Report & Adverse Action Notices

If an employer is considering rejecting you, rescinding a job offer, or taking another adverse employment action based in whole or in part on a background check, the FCRA generally requires the employer to first provide you with a pre-adverse action notice, a copy of the background check report it relied on, and a copy of A Summary of Your Rights Under the Fair Credit Reporting Act.

This is your opportunity to review the report before the employer makes its final decision. Scrutinize it for every inaccuracy, from incorrect criminal records to misreported employment dates or educational credentials. You can also request your complete file directly from the background check company, since the report provided to the employer may not contain everything in your consumer file.

If the employer ultimately decides against you based on the report, it must generally provide a separate final adverse action notice. That notice must include the name, address, and phone number of the background check company, explain that the company did not make the employment decision, and tell you about your right to dispute inaccurate information and obtain a free copy of your report if you request it within 60 days.

2. Dispute the Error with the Screening Company

File a formal dispute directly with the consumer reporting agency that generated the report. Consider submitting the dispute in writing and using a method that allows you to document when it was sent and received. Clearly identify each mistake, explain why it is incorrect, and include any supporting evidence you have, such as court documents showing that a case was dismissed or sealed or official records verifying your employment or education.

Keep copies of everything you send and proof of delivery. You generally do not need to determine exactly where the error originated before filing your dispute. The background check company is responsible for conducting a reasonable reinvestigation of disputed information.

3. Notify the Employer

Politely and professionally inform the hiring manager or HR department that the background check contains mistakes and that you initiated a formal dispute. In some cases, the employer may be willing to pause its decision while the disputed information is investigated.

Do this as quickly as possible after receiving the pre-adverse action notice. The purpose of the pre-adverse action process is to give you an opportunity to review the report and address potentially inaccurate information before the employer makes its final decision.  

4. Allow for the Investigation

The consumer reporting agency generally has 30 days to reinvestigate your dispute. In certain circumstances, that period may be extended to 45 days, including when you provide additional relevant information during the investigation.

The screening company must review the information you provide and notify the source that furnished the disputed information. If disputed information is found to be inaccurate, incomplete, or cannot be verified, it generally must be corrected or deleted. The consumer reporting agency must also provide you with written notice of the results of the reinvestigation within five business days after it is completed.

If the investigation results in a correction, you can ask the consumer reporting agency to send notice of the correction to anyone who received your report for employment purposes within the previous two years.

5. Escalate if Necessary

If the background check company fails to correct inaccurate information after you dispute it, you can consider filing a complaint with the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. You may also want to speak with a consumer protection attorney from Mistake.com about your rights.

If an inaccurate background check caused you to lose a job, have an offer rescinded, or suffer another financial or emotional harm, you may have a claim under the FCRA depending on the circumstances. Our attorneys can evaluate the screening company's investigation, the employer's adverse action process, and the specific harm you suffered to determine whether your rights were violated.

what to do if your background check is wrong mistake.com

What Should I Say to the Employer About a Wrong Background Check?

Tell the employer, in writing, that the background check report contains an error, that you’ve filed a dispute, and that you’ll share the corrected report as soon as you have it. Keep it short and factual. Here’s a message you can customize:

“Hello [Name], thank you for sharing my background check report. I’ve reviewed it and found information that isn’t accurate, including [one-line description of the error]. I’ve filed a formal dispute with [background check company] and will send you the corrected report as soon as I receive it. I’m still very interested in the role and would appreciate it if you could hold off on a final decision while the dispute is resolved.”

If the employer has already made a final decision, our guide to job denials from background checks explains what the employer was supposed to do before rejecting you and what your options are now.

How Can I Tell If My Background Check Is Wrong?

A background check may be wrong if it includes information that doesn’t belong to you, is outdated, is incomplete, or does not accurately reflect the underlying record. Use the Mistake.com Background Check Error Checklist below to compare each entry on your report with what you know about your own history.

Look for problems such as:

  • A criminal case you don’t recognize. This may be a mistaken identity or mixed-file error, where someone else’s record was matched to you because of a similar name, date of birth, or other identifying information.
  • A case you know was dismissed, expunged, or sealed. The background check may contain an outdated or improperly reported record because the screening company did not pick up a later court update or otherwise reported information that should not appear.
  • An arrest or charge with no outcome listed. This may be an incomplete record. For example, the report might show that you were charged with an offense but leave out the final disposition showing that the charge was dismissed or that you were acquitted.
  • The same case listed two or more times. These are duplicate entries, which can make a single incident appear to be multiple separate cases.
  • A misdemeanor listed as a felony, the wrong offense, or incorrect case details. This may be a misreported criminal record where the offense, severity, dates, disposition, or other details do not match the actual court record.
  • Wrong job titles, employers, or employment dates, or “unable to verify” next to a job you actually held. This may indicate an employment verification error in how your work history was collected, matched, or confirmed.
  • A degree, professional license, or other credential marked as unverified or missing. This may be an education or credential verification error, particularly if you can confirm the degree, license, or certification through official records.

Who Do I Contact If My Background Check Is Wrong?

Contact the background check company that prepared the report, because under the FCRA it has the legal duty to investigate your dispute and fix the information. The employer decides whether to hire you, but it can’t change the report. Employment background checks are run by companies like Checkr, First Advantage, HireRight, and Accurate Background.

When dealing with an inaccurate background check, it's important to understand who is responsible for what and who to contact to get the error corrected.

  • The Background Check Company: Prepares your background check report and is responsible for conducting a reasonable investigation when you dispute inaccurate information, including verifying disputed details with the original source when appropriate. You can request your complete consumer file, written investigation results, and that any corrections be communicated to the employer.
  • The Employer: Makes the final hiring decision and must provide you with a copy of your background check report and a summary of your FCRA rights before taking adverse action based on the report. You can ask the employer to allow additional time to resolve the dispute before making a final decision.
  • The Original Source (Court, Former Employer, or School): Provides the underlying information used in your background check. You generally do not need to contact the original source yourself, since investigating disputed information is the background check company's responsibility. However, obtaining supporting records directly from the source may help strengthen your dispute.

Is There a Deadline to Dispute a Background Check Mistake?

No. The FCRA doesn’t set a deadline for you to dispute a background check mistake. The 30-day clock you may have read about belongs to the background check company: it’s how long the company generally has to investigate once it receives your dispute.  

That said, while you're not up against a dispute clock and can file a dispute at your convenience, FCRA lawsuits for legal claims that arise out of reporting errors are subject to statutes of limitations. This means that the law only allows you to bring a lawsuit over these issues within two years of discovering the error or five years from when the error was first reported.  

And waiting can still cost you in the immediate moment because an employer’s hiring decision usually moves much faster than a dispute investigation. So, disputing as soon as you spot the error is the best strategy.

Will Fixing One Background Check Fix The Error Everywhere?

Not automatically. A correction applies to the report from the background check company you disputed with. Employers use many different screening companies, and each one keeps its own records. If Checkr fixes an error, but the next employer uses HireRight, the same wrong record can appear again if HireRight pulled it from the same source.

That’s why it pays to dispute instead of letting a wrong record slide. Keep your results letter from every dispute, and if the same error appears on a report from a different company, dispute it there too and include the earlier results as evidence.

Can I Get Compensation for a Background Check Error?

The FCRA recognizes the severe impact of these errors. If you can prove the mistake directly led to a lost job opportunity or other harm, you may be entitled to compensation including:

  • Lost wages and benefits you would have earned.
  • Damages for emotional distress and/or damage to your reputation.
  • Attorney’s fees and court costs.

Keep in mind that a corrected report doesn't automatically undo a decision an employer already made. The employer is not legally obligated to hire you just because their decision was based on an error that was ultimately corrected. But an employer may be legally liable for other associated harms, including failure to follow the proper steps during the rejection process.

If an inaccurate background check has cost you a job opportunity or caused other harm, contact Mistake.com for a free case review. Our consumer protection attorneys can evaluate your situation, explain your rights under the FCRA, and help determine whether you may be entitled to compensation.

Other Background Check Resources

FAQs

My background check shows a criminal record that isn’t mine. What should I do?

Dispute it in writing with the background check company and include proof of identity, like your full name, date of birth, and address history, that shows the record belongs to someone else. Mistaken identity often happens when a background check company matches records using only a name, or a name plus a birthday, instead of more reliable identifiers.

Why is my dismissed or expunged case still showing up on my background check?

Usually because the background check company pulled an older version of the court record and never picked up the update. A report should not include sealed or expunged cases, should not report dismissed cases older than seven years, and should show the outcome of all charges. You can dispute any of these errors.

How long does a background check company have to fix an error?

A background check company generally has 30 days from the date it receives your dispute, or up to 45 days if you send new information during the investigation. It then has five business days to send you the results.

Will my employer find out that I disputed my background check?

Generally, the employer learns about your dispute only if you tell them or ask the background check company to send them the corrected report. In most cases, telling them is the smart move, because it gives them a reason to wait for accurate information instead of moving on to another candidate.

Does it cost anything to fix a wrong background check?

No. Disputing an error with a background check company is free. If you work with Mistake.com, these cases are handled on contingency, which means you don’t pay anything upfront or out-of-pocket. If your case is successful, the FCRA’s fee-shifting provision requires the background check company to cover your legal fees, not you.

Can I sue the background check company for wrong information?

You may be able to, if the background check company reported inaccurate information, didn’t properly investigate your dispute, or reported something it shouldn’t have, and that error cost you something like a job offer. A free case review is the fastest way to find out whether you have a possible legal claim.

Table of contents
Attorney Review

Daniel Cohen

Daniel Cohen founded Mistake.com after watching hardworking people get hurt by errors they never made: A single wrong entry on a credit report or background check can cost someone a job, an apartment, or a loan that they wanted. For over 10 years, Daniel and his team have stepped in to fix these mistakes, often taking on some of the largest data and consumer reporting agencies in the country, always at no out-of-pocket cost to the client. Daniel is licensed to practice law in New York, Arizona and Virginia, and is a member of the National Association of Consumer Advocates.

Read More
superlayers logo